Editing Research/new digital reading experiences (section)

==== Comparing TTS ====

The next step was a more thorough auditing of various TTS services to determine their quality and their support for SSML.

'''Free option: Amazon Polly'''

https://aws.amazon.com/polly/

Amazon Polly provided unnatural sounding speech. There is a higher quality version available, but that could not be accessed from the Netherlands. It claims to support SSML, but its interpretation often sounds stunted.

'''Free option: Crikk'''

https://crikk.com/

Crikk works better out-of-the-box, but it does not support SSML so it can not be improved upon. In does support pauses, but nothing else.

'''Free option: Google TTS'''

https://cloud.google.com/text-to-speech

Google TTS works better than Amazon and supports SSML, but still the intonation remains very unnatural.

'''Paid option: Elevenlabs'''

https://elevenlabs.io/

Elevenlabs offers a trial of 10000 characters per month. It works much better than all the other options. It appears to do it’s own preprocessing to figure out the right intonation for each sentence. It doesn’t support SSML, but frankly it doesn’t need it.

Overall, there is more variation in quality between different TTS services than we expected, and the large players don’t necessarily seem to do best. However, looking at the pace of innovation in this area, we expect the quality to improve drastically in the coming years.

<span id="elective-immersive-reading"></span>